Crowd Sourcing Ben Franklin’s Bust

Ben Franklin Sculpture

Composite image of completed 3D prints, photographed before being shipped.

Ben Franklin rises again. Only, this time instead of being an undead character in a series of children’s books, Ben Franklinstein is the loving nick-name given to a project that crowdsources the 3D-printed reproduction of Jean-Antoine Houdon’s portrait bust of the inventor and founding father. For Todd Blatt, organizer of the project, this is his second crowdsourced 3D-printing project of the year.

In late January, various maker and 3D printing blogs were aflutter about a crowdsourced 3D printing project of a bust of George Washington. The group behind the project was We The Builders, consisting of six people (Todd Blatt, David Fine, Matthew Griffin, Amy Hurst, Ryan Kittleson, and Marty McGuire) who banded together during the Art Bytes hackathon at the Walters Art Museum in Baltimore, MD. After scanning Giuseppe Ceracchi’s portrait bust of Washington, they sliced the model into 110 sections and posted them on line. People registered to participate in the project, downloaded a section, and got to work printing their model.

Ben Franklin Sculpture

3D Illustration of how the Franklin bust was sectioned

“Shortly after we started, I got a request from 3D Print Show in NY that said, ‘if you finish well put it at the front of the show,'” Recalled Todd Blatt, who spearheaded the group. That lit a fire under the project, and the team had a rush to see the prints get completed and shipped. Blatt began asking friends, participants, and his social network to invite other friends. Files were tracked. People who had registered and downloaded a part were messaged through the website to learn if they would complete their print in time, the farthest coming from China.

George made it to New York with little time to spare, and has bounced around parts of Manhattan, Baltimore, Washington, DC, as well as a jaunt to SXSW in Austin. Reception was favorable. “It is new to people that you can make a large thing,” reflected Blatt, noting how some thought the work was a quilt because of it’s patch-work quality. “When people learn it came from all over the world: that is exciting. Not everyone has a printer. But when they know they can be involved, they want to sign up and get involved, and I get new people signing up all the time who are waiting for the next project.”

The next project began to take shape in July. Side-stepping anything presidential, the focus of the second crowdsourced project still supported a tongue-and-cheek reference to the founding of the country once Blatt discovered Houdon’s portrait bust of Ben Franklin. “Franklin was an inventor and a tinkerer,” noted Blatt, and the project, in a way, became a nod to one of our nation’s first hackers. Blatt further observed that Franklin didn’t file for any patents, citing a quote from Franklin’s autobiography regarding his belief that people should share their inventions freely and generously. In other words, Franklin was into an opensource community more than 200 years before it was fashionable.

To get the project off the ground, Blatt turned to someone he knew that already had scan data of Ben Franklin: Michael Raphael, founder of Direct Dimensions, a 3D scanning company in Owings Mills, MD. “I’ve known Michael Raphael for five years or so. He’s a friend and he has the best scanning stuff around… He did a scan of a [Houdon] replica, and he had it in the office already. So, I asked him and he sent it.” The scan data captured at Direct Dimensions involved an arm scanner, which uses a laser and captures more details. “When you scan something you get raster info. You don’t get a smooth surface: you get points,” explains Blatt.  “If you do that with a lower quality scanner you’ll see the triangles.” Since arm scanners are of higher quality than a hand scanner, and not as portable, the scan of the replica was done in the lab. With the amount of data captured, Blatt was able to scale the model up to nearly three-times its size: comparable in scale to the Washington bust created earlier in the year.

3D illustration of the scanned bust being cut into sections

Composite image of completed 3D prints, photographed before being shipped.

After prints were completed, individuals shipped the pieces to Blatt with a little reimbursement from Tinkerine Studios, a 3D Printer company that Blatt works for as VP of Market Direction. As pieces arrived by mid September, he took notice of the differences in materials. PLA and ABS parts were expected. However, some makers changed out filament colors, or used markers to color the plastic, creating a rainbow of colors in one built part. “George had a wood filament part, and we metal plated a part. This time for Ben I received a resin part, a piece made with bronze powder and PLA: 80% bronze by weight and someone did an acetone treatment on an ABS print, which smoothed the stepping in the z-axis. There’s also a part made of pla mixed with pha.” The nature of how this print was constructed might give cause to conserve the outcome, although the variety of  materials in the prints might make for a conservation issue. Blatt is less concerned, especially if the objects have limited exposure to sun and heat.  “I do think this stuff will be around for a long time. PLA they say is biodegradeable, but it isn’t going to just melt away.” And, as the nature of the project would suggest, if there was a problem with a part in the future, it can simply be reprinted and replace.

Completed Franklin bust.

Completed bust of Ben Franklinstein
photographed at the Silver Spring Maker Faire.

But the soul of the project is not so much within the final object created: it’s within the community it builds. Crowdsourced 3D printed projects are few at present. However, just as the desktop 3D printing market expanded exponentially in the last five years, it’s safe to assume the volume of crowdsourced 3D printing projects will explode in the coming years as well. Blatt is keeping his ears open to other crowdsourced projects, and through his network is telling others. On his radar currently is a project called E-Nabling the Future, a volunteer community that creates 3D printed prosthetic hands. It has Blatt reflecting beyond the production of patchwork replicas of Classical busts. “We’ll be faced with other challenges in the future where things need to be distributed really quickly. Ben Franklinstein indicates what can be done with the technology. With e-Nable we have people across the world who have printers and there are people with a need for prosthetics: There are so many other problems as a society that we can fix. Getting involved with this today is pretty neat.”

Check out this time-lapse video of Blatt and Marty McGuire assembling Ben Franklinstein.

By John Anderson

2 responses

  1. Pingback: Sausage Making: Maker Faires in the Nation’s Capital « re:sculpt | International Sculpture Center

  2. Pingback: Shapeways Blog - Designer Spotlight: Todd Blatt

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: